Comprehensive Examinations
PLEASE NOTE: This page has now been updated for the Spring 2007 semester.
All Students in the Doctoral Program in Clinical Audiology must pass written comprehensive examinations as part of the requirement to advance to Doctoral Candidacy. The following is intended to help you prepare for this process. Please contact the exam coordinator for additional information when necessary.
Table of Contents:
Prerequisites
The following prerequisites must be met in order to take
the comprehensive examinations:
back to top of page
Topic Areas
Students will complete seven examination questions, with each question designated 1.5 hours of examination time, for a total of 10.5 hours of examinations. The objective of the comprehensive exam is to test the overall knowledge base expected of doctorally-trained audiologists, as well as the ability to seek out and interpret new information of importance to audiologists. The comprehensive examinations are not designed to test specific knowledge acquired in each class, exclusively. Rather, the comprehensive examination questions are designed to be "cross-cutting" so that answers are not apparent from just one class. Moreover, the answers may well require information beyond that given in any class. It is the student's responsibility to research their reponses to questions. The distribution of the questions will be two questions in the area of Diagnostic Audiology, two questions in the area of Rehabilitative Audiology, two questions in the area of Hearing Science, and one question in the area of Research Methods. The relevant coursework covered in these broad topic areas is shown in Table 1.
Table 1: Coursework covered by each broad examination topic area (this list is not exclusive, and may include additional material taught in seminars)
-
In addition to the seven CAUD examination questions administered on campus, students choosing the Clinical Ph.D. path will be tested on one additional question. This question will pertain to the student's specific research area of interest. The student will have two days to answer this question, and the question will be given to the student following completion of the initial seven examination questions.
back to top of page
Location
The Comprehensive examinations are administered via
computer in the BSOS Open Labs in Lefrak Hall, Rooms 0225, 0227, 0229
and 0231. Only one or two of these rooms
will be used for the exams. A door sign, posted on the day
of the exam, and the definite testing schedule, will indicate
which one(s).
Students are expected to type responses to comprehensive
examination questions, using MS Word on the BSOS network
(note that Word Perfect is not available because it was
phased out from the network during the Fall of 2001). Students
are strongly encouraged to familiarize themselves with the
computer instructions and with the Open Labs in Lefrak Hall
prior to their comprehensive testing date.
back to top of page
Schedule
The examination questions will be administered over a period of two and 1/2 days, with a rest day between days one and two. During the first two days, there will be two questions given in the morning and one question given in the afternoon. The third day will consist of the remaining single question. Testing
typically takes place in the 1st-2nd week of November for Fall candidates and in the 1st-2nd week of April for
Spring candidates. The re-take day is typically scheduled
10-16 days after the second testing day. Every effort will be made to administer the examinations in a separate room designated for Audiology students only.
Comprehensive Exam Dates for Spring 2007 are April 25, 27, and 30.
Click here for Spring 2007 schedule (pdf)
back to top of page
Pre-Comps Meeting and Example Questions
The faculty will hold a preparation meeting prior to the administration of the comprehensive exams for those students taking the exam in a particular semester. Students will be informed of the objectives of the exam and expectations for performance on the exam.
The faculty will prepare a set of sample comprehensive examination questions for each comprehensive examination cycle. These questions will be distributed to students at the preparation meeting or at the beginning of the semester in which comprehensive examinations are administered. Each of the seven specific questions for the examination will be drawn from these sample questions in its entirety or in slightly modified form.
The faculty will also provide at least one example of an outstanding response to a mock comprehensive question, so that the students have a "gold standard" to emulate in preparing their own responses to the comprehensive exam questions.
back to top of page
Computer Instructions
Computer Instructions
The proctor will use the first half-hour of the first comprehensive testing day to give you the following computer instructions. However, you are encouraged to read them prior to the comprehensive testing days.
You are not allowed to bring your notes or books with you; please store them somewhere else. Neither food nor drink will be allowed inside the open labs. You will be assigned a PC. You will use the same PC throughout the entire examination day. Only you and the proctor will have access to it.
What you will receive from the proctor?
- A code number, which will be unique to you, to preserve your anonymity. This will be given on the first day of the exam. You will use the same code number for all topic areas for all exam days.
- A USB memory stick.
- A blank sheet of paper to organize your thoughts, which will be collected with your answer.
How to save your answers?
Your answers in each topic area should be saved in a single file. The file name of each topic area will be a combination of the topic area and your code number. For example, if you are writing on Research Methods and your code number is S02, your filename may be S02ResMeth.doc. Specific instructions regarding filenames will be given to you on the day of the exam.
- Use a header to number all your pages and label the top of every page with its filename.
- Save your answers on the C: drive AND on the USB Memory stick. Save your file every 10 minutes on both drives.
When you're done
- When you have finished answering the questions in a topic area, save your file and return the memory stick to the proctor. Also return the question sheet, scrap paper and the floppy disk to the proctor.
Exam Taking Tips
- Read carefully: for example, answering
a question about a 1-year old client as if it were a 5-year
old client is likely to result in a failed question, even
when the answer is correct for the 5-year old client
and even when after the test the professor finds that
the student knows the correct answer for the 1-year old
student.
- Be specific: most questions ask for
specific information about a topic. However, on occasion
some students may answer such questions by writing down
everything they know about the topic. It gives the impression
they did not read the question, may result in a failed
question, and unnecessarily takes up precious exam time.
- Be complete: provide all specific information
asked for in a question.
back to top of page
Grading System
Will grading be anonymous?
Yes. The identities of the students and examiners are anonymous throughout the grading process. This is why
you will be assigned a unique code number on the day of
the test. Should a re-test be necessary, then a new unique
code number will be assigned to the student taking the test.
Once the grades are submitted, students will be informed of the two (or three) graders for each question and the final exam outcome. Similarly, faculty will be informed of the identities of the students and their performance for each question. This permits students and faculty to contact each other for follow-up on the quality of the individual student's answers to the questions.
What grading system will be used?
Each question will be graded by a minimum of two members of the regular and/or adjunct faculty who have expertise in the examination topic area. The graders may or may not be the faculty members who taught some of this information to the students through coursework or independent study. Faculty members grading each question will assign a grade of High Pass, Pass, Low Pass, or Fail. The criteria for grading a question in each of these categories are described in Table 2.
Table 2: Criteria for comprehensive examination grading system
Hi Pass
|
All facts completely accurate, frequent citing of appropriate literature, comprehensive and thorough response to all aspects of the question, highly detailed. |
Pass
|
All facts accurate, some citing of appropriate literature, comprehensive response to the question, may be missing some minor detail. |
Low Pass
|
Generally accurate, one or two citations, broad response to question without much detail. |
Fail
|
Factual inaccuracies, no citations, doesn't completely answer the question. |
After the grades have been submitted, if the Exam Coordinator notes any disparity of two grades or more (for example, High Pass and Low Pass) for a student on a particular question, he/she will inform the relevant examiners. These examiners may discuss the grades submitted, and, following this discussion, a consensus grade may be reached by the examiners. If a consensus is not reached, a third expert will be asked to read and grade the student's question to resolve the disparity.
While we expect all of the doctoral students to pass the comps, sometimes a student fails a question. This would occur if two graders for a question both submit a grade of "Fail." In the event that only one grader submits a grade of "Fail," a third expert will be asked to read and grade the student's question. A student would then fail the question if two of the three examiners submit a grade of "Fail." In order to pass the comprehensive examination question, the average grade must be at least "Low Pass."
When can I expect to get my grade?
Please allow for a few weeks to receive your grades. Faculty members receive the answers to their topic area(s) on the day of examination and are given one-to-two weeks to complete their grading.
How will I find out about my grade?
Once all grades from the various topic areas have been received, the comprehensive exam coordinator will communicate your grades to you by email. There will be no deviation from this method of reporting results.
back to top of page
Retake Policy
- A student must pass all examination questions in order to be admitted to Doctoral Candidacy.
-
A student who fails more than one examination question
will be judged to have failed the comprehensive examination. The time-frame for re-taking the full set of comprehensive examinations will be determined by the faculty examination committee.
-
Any student who fails only one comprehensive
examination question may re-take that question during the
same semester. A new question
will be administered from the same topic area as the question that was failed.
- Clinical Ph.D. students will be permitted to re-take the single take-home question during the same semester, in addition to one of the basic seven comprehensive examination questions.
-
Students who fail to pass any re-administered question
areas will be required to take the entire comprehensive
examination over during a subsequent semester.
-
Any student may take the entire comprehensive examination
only twice. Failure to pass any questions on the second
full administration of the comprehensive examination will
result in termination from the program.
back to top of page
Academic Honesty
All students taking the comprehensive
examinations are expected to adhere to campus policy on
academic integrity. In particular, cheating and/or plagiarism
on the examinations will result in immediate referral to
the Student Honor Council.
back to top of page
Exam Coordinator
For further questions please contact the Department's
Coordinator of the Comprehensive Examinations:
Dr. Monita Chatterjee
mchatterjee@hesp.umd.edu
Information you must provide to the Exam Coordinator:
- What information?
- First name
- Last name
- Phone
- Email
- Address
- Semester and year of your comps
- Name of your academic advisor
back to top of page